Two market reports can give you two different sizes for the same market — and both can be honest. For a brand planning its first custom collectible, that is confusing. It is also normal. A market number is not a fact of nature. It is the result of a series of choices about what to count, and different researchers make different choices.
This article explains where those differences come from, the three questions to ask about any number before you trust it, and why search growth and sales growth are not the same thing. It uses one worked example throughout: the two most commonly quoted figures for the collectibles market.
Why the Same Market Has Different Sizes
The same market has different sizes because "collectibles" is not one thing. It is a word that covers many different products, sold through many different channels, in many different places. Every market study has to draw a line around what it counts, and where that line falls changes the total.
The differences usually come from three places.
First, categories. One study may count only figures and statues. Another may include trading cards, designer toys, blind boxes, and secondary-market sales. A third may include art objects and memorabilia as well. Each of these is defensible. None of them describes the same market.
Second, channels. Some studies count retail sales only. Others include direct-to-collector sales, crowdfunding, and resale platforms. A market that counts resale looks much bigger than one that counts first sales only — and neither is wrong, as long as the definition is stated.
Third, regions. A study that covers North America and Europe will produce a smaller number than one that also counts Asia, where blind-box and designer-toy sales are a large share of the total. A global figure and a regional figure are not two estimates of the same thing.
Take the two figures most often quoted for this market. Grand View Research puts the collectibles market at $306.44 billion in 2024, projected to reach $535.50 billion by 2033, at a compound annual growth rate of 6.6%. A second figure often quoted alongside it is $422.56 billion by 2030. These two numbers are sometimes placed side by side as if they were comparable. They are not. They come from different definitions and different base years. They are estimates of two different things that happen to share a name.
The lesson is simple: when two numbers disagree, the first question is not which one is right. It is what each one counted.
Three Questions to Ask About Any Number
Before you quote a market number — in a proposal, a pitch deck, or a meeting with a factory — ask three questions. If you cannot answer all three, treat the number as a headline, not as evidence.
- What year does it describe? A 2024 figure is a measurement. A 2033 figure is a projection. Projections depend on assumptions about growth, prices, and categories that may not hold. Never present a projection as if it were a fact, and never compare a figure from one year with a figure from another as if they were measured at the same time.
- What is included — and what is left out? Look for the definition. Does "collectibles" here mean figures and statues, or does it include trading cards, coins, and art? Does it count resale, or first sales only? Does it cover one region or the whole world? If the report does not say, that is itself useful information: the number cannot be checked, so it should not be quoted as if it could.
- Who published it, and how did they count? A figure from a named research firm with a stated method can be checked and challenged. A figure repeated without a source cannot. When you cite a number, name the source, the year, and the definition in the same sentence. That takes a few extra words, and it protects you from a question you cannot answer.
These three questions take less than a minute to ask. They are the difference between using a market report and being used by one.
Search Growth vs Sales Growth: Not the Same Thing
One of the most common mistakes in reading market reports is treating every kind of growth as the same kind of growth. Search growth, sales growth, and revenue growth are three different signals, and they do not move together.
Consider a real example. The eBay 2025 Collected Report records that searches for Labubu rose 2,600% year on year. That is a striking number. But it is a search number. It says that many more people typed the word into a search box. It does not say how many figures were sold, at what price, or how large the market for them is.
Search growth can mean many things: curiosity, a viral moment, resale interest, or people checking a price before deciding not to buy. A spike in searches can happen before sales rise, after sales have already peaked, or without sales rising at all. It is a signal about attention, not about money changing hands.
Sales growth is different: it counts units sold. Revenue growth is different again: it counts money received, which can rise because prices rose even if fewer units were sold. A report that says "sales up 470%" is not saying the same thing as a report that says "searches up 2,600%", and neither is saying the market as a whole grew by that amount.
For a buyer, the practical rule is this: never use a search figure to justify a production quantity. Search heat tells you people are looking. It does not tell you how many will buy, at what price, or through which channel. Production decisions need sales evidence — pre-orders, sell-through on comparable products, or a tested audience — not a search chart.
How to Cite a Market Number Without Overclaiming
Quoting a market number well is a small skill, and it is mostly about restraint. Four habits will keep a citation honest.
Name the source, the year, and the definition. “Grand View Research estimates the collectibles market at $306.44 billion in 2024” is a citable claim. "The collectibles market is worth $306 billion" is not — it drops the year, the source, and the scope, and it invites the reader to assume the figure means more than it does.
Do not mix figures from different definitions in one sentence. If one figure counts retail only and another counts retail plus resale, putting them side by side implies a comparison that does not exist. Use one figure, with its definition, or explain why you are showing two.
Do not present a projection as a fact. "Projected to reach $535.50 billion by 2033" is a forecast, not a measurement. Say so. A forecast is useful for planning; it is not evidence that the market will be that size.
Do not use a broad-market growth rate as a product forecast. A compound annual growth rate of 6.6% for the whole collectibles market does not mean your product category will grow at 6.6%, and it certainly does not mean your product will. Growth at the market level can come from a few fast-growing categories while others stay flat, or from higher prices rather than more units sold. For what a growth rate does and does not promise for a single product, see SEO 001 in this series, which works through the same Grand View figures in detail.
Overclaiming is not just a writing problem. It leads to bad decisions: quantities set from a headline, prices set from a growth rate, and timelines set from someone else's forecast.
What a Buyer Should Do Instead of Chasing the Biggest Number
If the biggest number is the least useful one, what should a buyer do instead? Three things, in order.
Look at your category, not the whole market. A buyer commissioning a resin statue, a PVC figure, or a 1/6 scale figure needs to know how that category behaves — its typical edition sizes, its price range, its buyers — not how the entire collectibles market behaves on average. Category behaviour is harder to find than a headline total, and it is worth far more.
Look at your buyer, not the average buyer. Collectors, fans, and gift buyers are not the same buyer, and they do not buy for the same reasons. A product succeeds when it reaches the right buyer through the right channel, not when the market as a whole grows. Pre-orders, community response, and sell-through on comparable products are better evidence than any market total.
Look at what can actually be delivered. A market number says nothing about whether a factory can make your product at the quality, quantity, and price you need. That is a separate question, and it is answered by a clear brief: defined size, defined material, defined quantity, and a sample you can check before production. The same discipline applies in both places. A market number without a definition cannot be compared, and a factory quote without defined specifications cannot be compared either.
That is also why a big market does not mean a high margin. Demand and cost are separate questions, and the cost side is covered in W34, which breaks down what actually drives the cost of manufacturing a custom collectible.
Market reports are useful when they are read carefully. They set the background: the category is not shrinking, new products can find buyers, and demand is not confined to one region. What they cannot do is make a decision for you. Read the definition, ask the three questions, keep search and sales apart, and cite with restraint. Then make the decision on the evidence that belongs to your product: your category, your buyer, and what your factory can deliver.
If you are planning a custom collectible and want to check the numbers behind it, send us your files — your reference images and a short description of what you want to make. We will confirm the definitions with you — size, material, quantity, and edition — before quoting, so the price you receive is for the product you actually described.
Mancheng Collectibles is an authorized OEM manufacturer based in Dalingshan Town, Dongguan, Guangdong, China, with 10+ years of team experience in resin statues and busts, PVC/ABS figures, 1/6 scale figures, and prop replicas and electronic collectibles. We manufacture under our clients' authorization; designs and IP belong to our clients. We are B2B only and do not publish prices; minimum order quantities are assessed per project. Contact us at elina.liu@manchengcollectibles.com.